AN EXAMINATION OF THE CAUSES OF JURISTIC DIFFERENCES IN INTERPRETATION IN ISLAMIC LAW
CHAPTER ONE
GENERAL INTRODUCTION
1.1 Introduction
It will be wrong for anyone to consider the divergent views of Muslim jurists (both early and present) on issues or matters as mere academic exercise. Differing is inevitable among mankind because of individual natural differences regarding thinking, understanding, power of assimilation, intellect, etc. Thus, differences and contradictions are a natural outcome. Allah The Most High says: “And if your Lord had willed, He could have made mankind one community; but they will not cease to differ”[1]
Texts under Islamic Law are general in their nature, and give room for interpretations. Some of the provisions from the Qur‟an are not opento interpretations. On the other hand, some of its provisions are open to different interpretations. Similarly, there are parts of the texts of Sunnah which are subjected to interpretations and there are some which are not. Some matters are neither expressly mentioned in the Qur‟an nor the Sunnah, and this is regarded as silence of the texts regarding them. This has made the jurists to develop some certain principles. The detailed texts found in the Qur‟an and the Sunnah according to the Islamic Jurists, are divided into four types as follows:
Texts which are definitive (qat‟iyyah) both in respect of authority and meaning.
Texts which are authentic in their authority but speculative (zanniy) in meaning.
Texts which are of doubtful authority, but definitive in meaning.
Texts which are speculative in respect to both authority and meaning[2]. Interpretation which gives room for decision or owing to opinion, does not apply to the first of the above categories, such as the clear provision (Nusus) concerning the prescribed penalties (Hudud) on the allocated shares (Furood) of inheritance both in the Qur‟an and SunnahAl-mutawatir (continuous Sunnah) that conveys definitive meaning. But interpretation can validly operate in regard to any of the remaining three types of texts[3].
Knowing the causes of juristic differences in interpretation under Islamic Law, helps in a long way, to overcome and at the same time to discard the blind following of one of the four major orthodox schools of Islamic Jurisprudence. The correctness of the orthodox interpretations was proportional to their innate capabilities and to the types and quantity of legal authorities (adillah) available to them at the time of making rulings. It is based on these facts, that the early jurists prohibited their followers from blind following in all aspects and disliked disagreement, as it has shown in their actual statements:
Abu – Yoosuf, Ya‟qoob, disciple of Imaam Abu Haneefah, reported that the Imaam once told him, “Woe be on you, Yaqoob. Do not write down all you hear from me, for surely I may hold an opinion today and leave it tomorrow, hold another tomorrow and leave it the day after”[4].
Ibn „Abdil-Barr reported that Imaam Maalik once said:
“Verily I am only a man, I err and am at times correct; so thoroughly investigate my opinions, then take whatever agrees with the Book and the Sunnah, and reject whatever contradicts them”[5].
Imam Ash-Shaafi‟ee stressed a very important point concerning personal opinion versus the Sunnah where he said:
“The Muslims (of my time) were of a unanimous opinion that one who comes across an authentic Sunnah ofThe Holy Prophet (peace be upon him) is not allowed to disregard it in favor of someone else‟s opinion”[6].
[1] Ali, A.Y. (1938) : The Holy Qur’an, The Islamic Foundation, United Kingdom, 3rd edition, Chap.11 :118. This translation is used throughout the work.
[2] Kamali, M.H. (1991): Principles of Islamic jurisprudence, Islamic Text Society, Malaysia, 2nd
Edition, p.316,see also, Nyazee, I.A.K. (2000): Islamic jurisprudence, Islamic Research
Institute, Islamabad,1st edition, p.148
[3] Ibid, p. 316-317, see also, Khalaaf A. (2010): Ilmu Usul Fiqu, Daral-Ghad Al-
Gadeed, Egypt, p. 238
[4] Philips, B. A. (1990): The Evolution of Fiqh, International Islamic publishing House, 3rd Edition, p.119, Al-albaanee,M.N. (nd): Sifatus Salaatin Nabiy, Maktabatul Mu‟arif,Riyad,
P.47
[5]Philips, B. A., op. cit., p.121, Al-albaanee, M.N. op. cit., p.48
[6] . An-Nawawee, M.Y. (nd): al-Majm’u,Vol.1, P.63,htt:www.mktaba.org, Philips, B.A., op. cit., P. 122, al-Albaanee, M.N., op. cit., p.50
tadalafil daily use tadalafil pills 20mg
tadalafil 40 mg daily
tadalafil generic: http://tadalafilonline20.com/ what is tadalafil
pills without a doctor prescription: https://genericwdp.com/ buy medication without an rx
generic pills generic pills without a doctor prescription
prescription drugs without a doctor overseas pharmacies shipping to usa
india pharmacy: https://genericwdp.com/ india pharmacy mail order
india pharmacy sildenafil without doctor prescription
over the counter viagra viagra without a doctor prescription
viagra without a doctor prescription
viagra discount where to buy viagra online
viagra over the counter walmart
viagra price viagra amazon
generic viagra walmart
buy viagra online canada viagra without a doctor prescription usa
viagra without a doctor prescription usa
viagra from canada buy viagra online usa
п»їviagra pills
online doctor prescription for viagra generic viagra walmart
how much is viagra
viagra over the counter buying viagra online
when will viagra be generic
order viagra online best place to buy generic viagra online
cheap viagra online
viagra amazon buying viagra online
viagra cost
viagra online usa п»їviagra pills
when will viagra be generic
can you get propecia without a prescription finasteride 5mg
best male enhancement
valtrex online canada valtrex 500mg coupon
where to buy chloroquine chloroquine
sexual dysfunction in men
where to buy chloroquine chloroquine tablets buy
where can i buy viagra over the counter https://viagrapills100.com/ viagra 100mg price
best over the counter viagra https://viagrapills100.com/ viagra from india
how much is viagra https://viagrapills100.com/ online doctor prescription for viagra
cost of viagra https://viagrapills100.com/ viagra amazon
buying viagra online https://viagrapills100.com/ buy generic 100mg viagra online
where to buy viagra online https://viagrapills100.com/ viagra from india
cheap ed pills from india buy ed drugs
ed pills online
natural ed cheap ed pills in mexico
order ed pills
buy ed pills buy ed drugs online
ed pills without a doctor prescription
order ed pills cheap ed pills in mexico
cheap ed pills
hydroxychloroquine 5 mg: buy plaquenil – hydroxychloroquine sulfate nz
http://gabapentinst.com/# neurontin 100mg caps
buy hydroxychloroquine sulfate: generic plaquenil – plaquenil buy online
http://hydroxychloroquinest.com/# where to buy plaquenil
neurontin cream: 800mg neurontin – gabapentin generic
how much is prednisone 5mg: buy prednisone – prednisone price canada
http://gabapentinst.com/# neurontin 600
https://zithromaxproff.com/# zithromax antibiotic without prescription
zithromax 500mg price
http://zithromaxproff.com/# where to get zithromax over the counter
zithromax cost canada
https://zithromaxproff.com/# zithromax order online uk
how to get zithromax
http://zithromaxproff.com/# how to get zithromax over the counter
zithromax for sale usa
http://zithromaxproff.com/# zithromax drug
zithromax antibiotic without prescription
order bactrim online: minomycin for sale
fucidin capsules
buy minocin: buy terramycin online
order doxycycline online
order clindamycin online: buy clindamycin
buy doxycycline generic
buy augmentin generic: buy terramycin
tinidazole tablets
buy prescriptions from india pharmacy: india pharmacies online meds from india
best online international pharmacies india: order prescription drugs from india india pharmacies shipping to usa
reputable online pharmacies in india: trusted india online pharmacies india pharmacies shipping to usa
india pharmacy mail order: india pharmacy india pharmacies online
india pharmacy drugs: usa pharmacy india overseas pharmacies shipping to usa
best erectile dysfunction pills review: viagra pills levitra pills
kamagra pills: best male erectile dysfunction pill ed pills for sale
red erectile dysfunction pill: male erectile pills viagra pills
free adult personals
free adult personals
kamagra pills: ed pills for sale ed pills for sale
cheapest generic viagra buy viagra without prescription buy viagra online without prescription
order viagra online viagra without a doctor prescription canada viagra without a prescription
canadian viagra non prescription viagra viagra without a doctor prescription
free local dates
free adult chat sites
mail order viagra viagra without prescription viagra no prescription
meet singles online
dating site
http://doxycyclinest.com/# generic for doxycycline